Sherwood Forest, tucked perfectly in the leafy heart of Winston-Salem, might first charm you with its quiet streets and family-friendly vibes. But wander down Robinhood Road or meander through the intersections of Peace Haven and Country Club, and you’ll quickly realize: this neighborhood is also a dream come true for food lovers. From cozy bakeries to trendy cafés, stellar ethnic cuisine to bustling food trucks, Sherwood Forest has cultivated a deliciously eclectic local food culture that invites both adventurous palates and comfort-seeking diners alike.
Classic Favorites and Neighborhood Institutions
No journey through Sherwood Forest’s food scene would be complete without mentioning Midtown Café & Dessertery. Anchoring the neighborhood at the intersection of Robinhood and Peace Haven, this iconic all-day eatery is cherished for its cheery ambiance and vast menu. Whether you’re fueling up on hearty omelets and fluffy pancakes for breakfast, savoring their legendary tomato basil soup for lunch, or capping the night with a towering slice of coconut cake, Midtown is that reliable spot where everyone feels at home. Prices are moderate, with generous portions and a bakery case that tempts even the strongest-willed visitor.
Strolling further down Peace Haven Road, you’ll find Fratellis Italian Steakhouse, a slightly upscale yet welcoming gathering place known for its perfectly seared steaks and classic Italian specialties—think house-made pastas, chicken parmesan, and wood-fired pizzas. Fratellis’ romantic but relaxed atmosphere makes it ideal for both family celebrations and date nights, with entrées usually in the $20–$40 range.
International Eats: Flavors from Afar
Sherwood Forest quietly boasts some of the city’s most authentic international eateries. Korner Cafe, nestled right on Country Club Road, is a beloved Greek diner where locals rave about the gyros, spanakopita, and fresh Greek salads. The friendly vibe and speedy service — not to mention reasonable prices — make Korner Cafe a lunch hour staple.
Just around the corner, Putters Patio & Grill infuses Southern hospitality with creative American pub fare. Here, the burgers are juicy, the fried pickles crisp, and the wings sport flavors ranging from mild to blazing hot. Gather here after Little League games or unwind on their covered patio with an ice-cold beer.
Craving something a little different? Wasabi Japanese Restaurant (Robinhood Road) consistently draws sushi fans and lovers of hibachi classics alike. The modern, inviting space makes it a go-to for weeknight dinners or special occasions. Sushi rolls are beautifully plated, and their bento boxes deliver a satisfying mix of flavors and textures—all at an approachable mid-range price point.
Sweet Treats and Bakeries Worth a Detour
If there’s one spot that makes every bakery enthusiast’s list in Sherwood Forest, it’s undoubtedly Dewey’s Bakery (Robinhood Plaza). With roots tracing back to 1930, Dewey’s is synonymous with Winston-Salem’s signature sweet — Moravian sugar cake. The aroma of cinnamon and brown sugar wafting through the shop instantly revives childhood memories for many locals. From rich, seasonal cakes and cookies to their iconic cheese straws, Dewey’s shines year-round, especially during holiday seasons.
Don’t overlook Bagel Station II on Robinhood Road, where fresh, New York-style bagels fly off the racks every morning. Whether you love a classic lox and cream cheese or adventurous spreads like jalapeño or honey walnut, this café’s laid-back charm and wallet-friendly prices make it an essential breakfast or brunch stop.
Coffee fiends should make a beeline for West End Coffeehouse, tucked into Robinhood Road’s lively shopping plazas. Locals treasure the expertly brewed coffee, indulgent pastries, and seasonal specialty drinks. With cozy seating and a handwritten menu that changes daily, it’s easy to lose an hour here reading or catching up with friends.
Food Trucks and Casual Eats
The Sherwood Forest area, especially near Robinhood Plaza, has cultivated a small but exciting food truck scene. On weekends, you might find Bandito Burrito slinging massive burritos stuffed with zesty meats and fresh salsas, or The Grinder Café, a mobile kitchen known for melt-in-your-mouth paninis and rich, foamy espresso drinks.
For a nostalgic treat, track down Big Winston’s Shave Ice during the warmer months. Their rainbow-hued, icy confections provide a cooling respite from North Carolina’s summer heat and are a huge hit with kids — and their parents.
Hidden Gems and Local Rituals
If you’re after something truly off the radar, step inside Osaka at Reynolda Manor Shopping Center just a stone’s throw from Sherwood Forest proper. This no-frills Japanese spot surprises with ultra-fresh sashimi and bento boxes that rival pricier downtown establishments.
Locals know that the Robinhood Road corridor is the go-to for morning pastries, with several neighborhood bakeries tempting commuters and early risers alike. Frequenters of Midtown Café never skip the glass display of rotating seasonal desserts, while families swear by stop-offs at Dewey’s for weekend treats.
Looking for a laid-back dinner after a walk in Jamison Park? La Carreta Mexican Restaurant (Robinhood Road) serves vibrant plates of tacos, enchiladas, and fajitas, all loaded with color and flavor. The margaritas are legendary, and the staff greets regulars like old friends—a fitting end to any neighborhood adventure.
Why Sherwood Forest’s Food Scene Stands Out
What makes the Sherwood Forest area’s dining scene so satisfying? It’s the blend of long-loved classics and up-and-coming gems, sidewalk cafés and bustling patios, where the sense of community is every bit as strong as the flavors. There’s a welcoming, down-to-earth spirit to the kitchens here: owners greet you by name, servers remember your “usual,” and every meal, from a simple bagel to a celebratory steak, feels special.
So next time you’re in Winston-Salem, skip the downtown crowds and let yourself wander the winding streets of Sherwood Forest. With a little curiosity and an appetite, you’ll find that this neighborhood is serving up some of the city’s most memorable bites—from sunrise to sunset.